The anti-ecstasy bill, say civil libertarians and reduction advocates, could easily be used against programs like DanceSafe. "When you prohibit information about use, you are targeting people involved in harm reduction," says Rachel King, legislative counsel for the American Civil Liberties Union. She adds that "there are not that many people who care about the First Amendment in the context of the war on drugs."

Those prosecuted for distributing information on the use of E and other club drugs would face a maximum prison sentence of 10 years along with fines.

"I don’t think it’s unreasonable for politicians to be worried," says Mark Kleiman, a professor of policy studies at UCLA. He points to studies from England showing that frequent weekend users of ecstasy are depressed by midweek, every week. "But passing a law that’s grossly unconstitutional is a different question," he says.

He has no doubt that if the legislation becomes law, the courts will throw it out. This, he says, is "part of a childish cycle the legislature has set up where the courts are the only ones left to defend the Constitution. They can vote for this knowing it’s going to get thrown out, but then they get to go home and tell their constituents that they’re doing something about drugs."

Chad Thevenot of the Criminal Justice Policy Foundation says it's ludicrous to block safe-drug information in the name of drug-abuse prevention. He draws an analogy to safe-sex programs. "Giving someone a condom doesn't make them horny; they're horny by nature," he says. "People make better decisions when they have better information."

There is no good research on the effectiveness of harm-reduction efforts. But there is solid evidence that the official approach to drug information has done nothing to stop drug use. Marijuana use among high school students nearly doubled from 1991 to 1999, according to the Centers for Disease Control -- years when the "just say no" slogan made famous by Nancy Reagan became the cornerstone of school-based drug education. Use of cocaine more than doubled in the same period.

"All of our research has shown that the messages so far don’t work," says Joel Brown, executive director of the Center for Educational Excellence in Berkeley, Calif. Young people, he says, don't fall for scare tactics, and often turn to uninformed sources who may downplay the risks.

"You have to win people's trust," says Sferios. "If part of the overall strategy is to see the drug situation as a war, well ... the first casualty in war is the truth."

Sferios and others point to a recent example in Florida, a hotbed of rave culture, of what happens when the government tries to control information related to drugs. As reported by Henry Pierson Curtis in a May 21 Page 1 article in the Orlando Sentinel, Florida drug czar Jim McDonough, a former Army colonel, was so eager to show that his efforts against club drugs were necessary that his office grossly overstated the number of deaths caused by them. The Sentinel reviewed the autopsy reports of those supposedly killed by club drugs in Central Florida, their main coverage area. Over a three-year period, they found that at least 35 of the 60 deaths were in fact completely unrelated to ecstasy or rave culture.

Two days after the story appeared, Graham introduced the ecstasy bill. DanceSafe is reviewing the Florida autopsy reports, and will publish its own conclusions.

A therapeutic dose (2mg/kg of body weight) of MDMA will flood the synapses of brain cells with nearly the entire supply of the brain's serotonin, and prevents it from being naturally recycled so it lingers longer. Serotonin is a neurotransmitter known to play an important role in determining a person's mood and regulation of body temperature. MDMA also triggers the release of dopamine and norepinephrine, which increase the feeling of energy. The three- to five-hour effect is usually one of seemingly boundless energy, combined with an overall heightened physical sensitivity and an increased feeling of empathy toward others. Hence the "marriage made in heaven," cited by one raver, between ecstasy and dancing in close quarters with lots of other people.

Ecstasy is most likely not without biological risks, but its effects on the brain are unclear. The most often cited studies on the neurotoxicity of MDMA are by Dr. George Ricuarte, a neurotoxicolgist at Johns Hopkins University. Ricuarte says MDMA causes damage to the ends of axons and may impair memory function. Other scientists, however, say his findings are inconclusive.

Dr. Julie Holland, a psychiatrist at Bellevue Medical Center and a psychopharmacologist in Manhattan, says Ricuarte's memory study compared multiple drug users with graduate students. "The best you could say from a study like that is that people who take a lot of drugs and go to raves don't perform as well on memory tests as grad students," Holland says.

She adds, "Nothing is conclusive about the brain and its chemistry -- the more you look, the more complicated it gets."

Her suggestion to ravers: "Use the chill-out rooms and stay cool. Drink plenty of water, but only as much as you feel you're losing. And get your pills tested."

A couple of hours before the finish of the rave on Randall's Island, an emergency medical technician, who has worked for several years at venues like Madison Square Garden and Yankee Stadium, is impressed. "It's much better than we expected," she said. "With two hours to go, we've only taken five people to the hospital, one was because of alcohol and another because he got in a fight. The other three ... we don't know what happened."

A leap of faith: The other three were probably not the three young people who decided against taking DXM pills disguised as ecstasy after having them tested by DanceSafe.

Sign up to receive free e-mail updates from Salon -- now in 17 different varieties!